Subject lines with a higher open rate. Can you share yours?
Business Marketing with Nika
47 replies
That one short line that changes everything. Especially the number of people who continue reading your newsletter. 🙂
From the very beginning I started writing newsletters, my best performing were:
1️⃣ Open rate: 53.3 %
Subject line: What can help you with Twitter's growth? 🚀
Preview text: And is Twitter premium worth it? 🤔 Thoughts from the YouTube interview
2️⃣ Open rate: 51.2 %
Subject line: One Year on Product Hunt and Community Building
Preview text: My observations and thoughts that I reflected on during this time.
3️⃣ Open rate: 47.4 %
Subject line: Twitter Premium Experiment: I bought a Blue Checkmark for 1 month. This is what happened
Preview text: These 3,000 followers on the Product Hunt 🔥 , new collaboration and Twitter Premium
4️⃣ Open rate: 47.3 %
Subject line: Can you conquer the world with your "faceless" brand? 🥷
Preview text: Let's find an answer together. Or not?
5️⃣ Open rate: 47.2 %
Subject line: 10 tips: Prepare your start-up for the conference 🚀
Preview text: I learned this at the Slush conference; it can help you present your business
6️⃣ Open rate: 43.8 %
Subject line: STEAL attention using these emotions 👀
Preview text: But be careful. Otherwise, you can make a lot of enemies.
7️⃣ Open rate: 42.7 %
Subject line: Are you loud enough in your business? 📣
Preview text: Not being annoying but being visible at the same time is (not) a science
Do you have any examples of good subject lines that outperformed other emails in the open rate?
BTW: In the comments is a form for signing up to my newsletter. 🙂
Replies
IK@ik_pegasi
Sure, here are a few subject lines that have worked well for us: "Unlock Exclusive Business Growth Tips Inside!" and "Don't Miss Out: Your Marketing Strategy Needs This."
Share
minimalist phone: creating folders
@ik_pegasi It looks like the AI Grabbed from my handle the "business" and "marketing" keywords and created 2 subject lines. Thank you, I haven't been able to use AI in my whole life. I am glad that someone did it for me.
Sales Likelihood Calculator
subject: "Your download ..."
minimalist phone: creating folders
These headlines are very "clickbaity" I found out that if you go a little bit off path with headlines, you can get more traction. Because people don't get that initial, ahh this is just clickbait. They lurk more if the headline is a bit different from what is to be expected.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@sentry_co can you share a good example of the headline? Ideally it could be proved by numbers in open rates.
@busmark_w_nika As the SoMe hell....I-mean-*land*-scape 😈 continues to be saturated by cheapskate clickbait headlines for quick wins (because of the AI-era). The pendulum swings back to more authentic experiences. As such my theory is that we will see an insurgence of more eclectic and original headlines. These are not that easy to scale tho, requires finesse, timing and skill. And can't be generated by an AI, at least not yet. An example, since you asked, Would be my post on PH 2 weeks ago. "Amplify your storytelling by blending these AI writing tools 🤖" https://www.producthunt.com/disc... (this headline felt more original, the lurker hock was in the word "blending" and Amplifying felt more in tune with the idea that AI should enhance humans, not replace them, which a lot of people currently have an anxiety for atm) I had 10 other ideas for headlines. But they were all: Too bullish, too clickbaity. Like: "Level Up Your Storytelling with These Mind-Blowing AI Writing Tools!" 😅
minimalist phone: creating folders
@sentry_co the answer is somewhere in the middle. You need to grab the attention somehow but it means a lot how you say it. and what words you will use. The worst part happens when you need to fit into 80 characters so people can read the whole line. The only way to "cheat" the system is A/B/C/D testing of options with mass mailing of the campaign winner to the rest of the subscribers. I haven't tried it from this MailChimp account yet but it's time to try it. 🤘
@busmark_w_nika Or just ask your superstar homies what resonates the most 😏 Quality > Quantity
That's a great list with good numbers. I am just here for the knowledge :)
minimalist phone: creating folders
@vaibhavdwivedi TBH, I am there for the knowledge too :D Because I am not completely satisfied with my results :D
@busmark_w_nika Haha, wonderful.
I was surprised that best performing line is a straightforward "brute force" one
minimalist phone: creating folders
@kostyabolsh Am I too invasive? :D
minimalist phone: creating folders
@kostyabolsh if you disagree with me :D you can :D I like when people debate with me their angle of view :D But if you think it is really awesome, thanks :)
@busmark_w_nika nope, i believe this is honest and awesome
Wow, something worth of stealing 😅
minimalist phone: creating folders
WorkHub
Open Rate: 53%
Boost Efficiency and Cut Costs in {Company Name} with AI
minimalist phone: creating folders
The exhausting sign-up form:
https://mailchi.mp/1dbd72e09689/...
These are the best performing subject lines for us so far
(it's only been 14 weeks and 1K subscribers)
Open Rate: 69%
Subject Line: Do your market research in minutes, not hours
Preview text : Why you should use Perplexity AI to get better market insights
Open Rate: 59%
Subject Line: Analyze Your Competition Faster Than Your Morning Coffee Brews
Preview text : Stop wasting time manually filling out Notion tables and Google Sheets. Focus on high-quality competitive analysis instead.
Open Rate: 54%
Subject Line: Spy Your Competitors From Your inbox or slack
Preview text : You actually don't even need Slack for this tutorial 😏.
Open Rate: 51%
Subject Line: 4 (free) AI tools that changed my Product Discovery
Preview text : How I turned a 10 hours process into 35 minutes of work
Open Rate: 50%
Subject Line: My Favorite AI Assistants (and how you can build your own).
Preview text : You can use these fine tuned specific AI assistants for your daily tasks
Hope it can help.
PS : you can check the content here : https://theproductcourier.substa...
minimalist phone: creating folders
@busmark_w_nika Thanks for your support !
You're right, how to save time is a key topic for people to read about.
As well as : make more money / get higher Status / be healthier ! 😅
Launching soon!
You've got some crazy high open rates!!! any secret?
minimalist phone: creating folders
Launching soon!
@busmark_w_nika that checks out - how big is the mailing list?
minimalist phone: creating folders
Nice Nika, Keep sharing such a valuable information.
While open rates and subject lines are important, it's crucial to consider segmentation and other related metrics for a fair comparison. That said, here are a few of my top performers:
1️⃣ Open rate: 50.9%
Subject line: How We Grew Our {{one of my client name}} Revenue by 200% in Just 12 Months 🚀
Preview text: A behind-the-scenes look at our successful marketing strategy.
2️⃣ Open rate: 52.8%
Subject line: {{first.name}}, Build Your First No-Code App This Weekend 🛠️
Preview text: A step-by-step guide just for you, to create your first app without any coding.
3️⃣ Open rate: 34.3%
Subject line: Unlock These 5 Growth Hacks to Skyrocket Your Startup 🚀
Preview text: {{first.name}}, Proven strategies you can implement today to accelerate your business growth.
Wow, those subject lines are as catchy as a startup pitch at a demo day! 🚀 When it comes to open rates, they've got the secret sauce. Have you ever crafted a subject line that felt like striking gold in a crowded inbox?
Almeta ML
[product name] - Your Request (works great for new signups)
Hey @busmark_w_nika! 😄 Your subject lines are super compelling and it's fascinating to see how effective they've been with such high open rates! I especially love 'What can help you with Twitter's growth? 🚀.' It's intriguing and clearly resonates with your audience. One of my best-performing subject lines was 'Unlock Your Growth Potential: 5 Proven Strategies ✨,' which garnered a 49% open rate. Looking forward to more insights and definitely signing up for your newsletter! 😍
minimalist phone: creating folders
minimalist phone: creating folders
@busmark_w_nika LOL, nah, I've seen this in too many videos from Tiktok/Youtube/INS
What's a common problem you wish there was a better product for?
minimalist phone: creating folders
@rahul_agarwal23 Do you think it would be a good topic for a subject line? Or what do you exactly mean by that?
I almost always run an A/B test for subject lines, and we've seen good results so far :)
For example, our feature launch emails:
Instant Link Confirmation is here! 🦝 - Open Rate 75%
Say Hi to Bulk Site Submission - Open Rate 61.54%
Or when we announced our blog:
The link-building blog you've been waiting for 📢 50% Open Rate
Link-building secrets, straight from the Raccoon's den 🦝 50% Open Rate
minimalist phone: creating folders
@natalia_toth Are you concentrating on email marketing topic right? :) Just to know any idea about your audience interest :)
I’ve been sending comic strips as emails, so depending on the story, I use subject lines like
“✨a short comic on someone like you”
“ 🙋🏼brad pitch has something to say”
(Yes, Brad Pitch is a character in our comics that looks like Brad Pitt, and he pitches our product)
The first one is the opening cold mail which gets like 50-60% open rate. And the second one will be a follow up to those who read the first mail and that gets 95% open rate.
The best tip for cold mail is run a bounce check on your email list to filter out bad emails.
And some things I’ve noticed anecdotally is that you should ideally keep subject shorter than 7 words, and if you’re using emojis, use it in the beginning because it has a lower chance of being hidden in mobile screens. Also subject lines with all small caps tend to do better that emails like “Quick Question for You” where the words are capitalized.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@sreenington that is pretty cool – I mean that idea with Brad Pitch! :D Definitely a great idea :D Nice! Thank you for your sharing. The last question: Which email provider service do you use for newsletters?
@busmark_w_nika used to use Beehiv, then I ended up making a platform with nextjs and AWS SES for me alone. Developer things 😎
minimalist phone: creating folders
@sreenington I am jealous of you because of that :D you are able to create any solution for your needs haha :D
@busmark_w_nika it’s like one of those instances where you spend 50 hours to automate something which takes 5 minutes. I do this all the time 🤦
Super interesting, seeing your hooks. It's interesting to see what people open and don't.
minimalist phone: creating folders