Is Hadith Literature a Reliable Source of History?

mahmoud afify
2 replies
https://en.al-dirassa.com/is-hadith-literature-a-reliable-source-of-history/ The modern method of historical criticism, which has evolved since the time of renaissance and enlightenment in Europe, has radically changed the historical evaluation of biblical sources in Western academia. The stories of the prophets were turned into religious myths, and historical personalities were studied instead of their mythical counterparts. Thus, today we have historical Moses vis a vis mythical Moses. And historical Jesus vis a vis mythical Jesus. However, in the Islamic academia, since the times of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ it was apparently clear for Muslim scholars that the stories found in the bible, called as Israʼiliyyat (Arab. اسرائیلیات‎),  were not historically reliable. These scholars either totally dismissed them or narrated them for the sake of their own interest, but never as a serious source of history. At the same time, Muslims not only dismissed what was unreliable, but they have also developed an unprecedented critical method for the verification of historical narrative – the ulum al-hadith (sciences of hadith).

Replies

maddy jacobs
Good afternoon! I'm hoping to connect with fellow literature lovers. I'm on the lookout for a space where I can expand my literary horizons. If you have any leads, I'd truly appreciate your input!
Adam Delong
The "Featured Authors" section on this site showcases notable writers and their literary works. The concise author profiles provide a glimpse into their writing styles and body of work, making it easier for readers to discover new authors. The inclusion of links to the authors' official websites allows for further exploration of their works, which I found particularly useful. However, it would be interesting to see more diverse voices represented in this section, expanding the range of reading experiences available.