Shorts vs TikTok vs Reels
Philipp Shay
39 replies
I tried out my own social media experiment.
Here's what I did:
1) I created brand new accounts on YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram with no followers.
2) Then, I made a short video about my trip to Bosnia using my own content.
3) I posted it on all three platforms: YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram.
4) Afterward, I looked at the results.
#1 TikTok performed the best with 273 views
#2 YouTube Shorts with 235 views
#3 Instagram Reels had less than 200 views
Which short video platform do you use?
Replies
Yuki Ogino@oginokairan
Morph
Shorts!
Share
In japan, Tiktok is the best.
Skylead
Shorts
Hunted Space
Not using any of those yet but thinking whether we should start implementing it for Klu..
TikTok has the largest music library of the three platforms, followed by Reels and then Shorts.
I would prefer to use You Tube Shorts.
I can only confirm this experience.
I would go even further and try to promote my stuff on Twitter (X), Reddit, etc.
As a user I use only YT Shorts, becuase the do not support nudity in their content, while tik tok and reels are full of this. What you think?
Reels and Shorts
@nitheesh_seshadri2 is it your own experience?
SearchPie
In my opinion, TikTok is more popular with young users and it's known for viral content, while Shorts is more focused on educational and informative content for older users. So it depends on your target audiences ^^
Youtube Shorts
In Usa, Shorts is the best!❤
@dorothy_dent really? I thought TikTok is so efficient in US
TikTok is the most popular short-form video platform!
Shorts & Reels.
