• Subscribe
  • Design Best Practices: From Lexus Engineer to Modular Furniture Maker

    Published on
    May 8th, 2019
    Category
    Makers
    Share On
    Sejun Park applied some of the best-in-class design practices he learned making cars to a practical need: affordable furniture that can adapt to our changing lives.
    I started Aalo back in 2017, after realizing that furniture shopping tends to be full of compromises. Affordable "fast furniture" employs low-quality materials, and high-quality brands usually require a big budget. On top of that, I couldn’t find a furniture option at any price point that was flexible enough to adapt to my frequently changing space needs. Given my background as a manufacturing engineer—I was working for Lexus, a division of Toyota, at the time—I set out to tackle this problem.
    While thinking about how to build a more attainable, adaptable, and sustainable furniture option, I took inspiration from some of the key aspects of the Toyota Production System, particularly the concepts of "elimination of muda (waste)," “genchi genbutsu (go and see the problem),” and "kaizen (continuous improvement)." By maximizing the use of common parts throughout the product line, I realized that we could eliminate a lot of inefficiencies in manufacturing and logistics, while continuously expanding the applications of the modular system.
    I iterated on these concepts as I learned how to build my first product, and again as I prepared to debut my 2.0 line, which includes a modular side table, garment rack, coffee table, desk, and bookshelf.
    In this photo essay, I’ll show you how I adapted my designs and landed on the project I’m launching on Kickstarter now.

    The sky’s the limit for first prototypes

    Early ideas of mostly impractical connector concepts.
    Early ideas of mostly impractical connector concepts.
    My initial idea for Aalo was to build an all-in-one DIY system capable of building furniture or any other kind of structure—almost like Lego for practical uses. I started with an open-ended approach, designing as if there were no constraints in cost, manufacturability, or functionality.
    These early concepts had multiple custom parts and complex geometry, making them almost impossible to be mass produced at a reasonable cost. They also needed a good deal of improvements in fit and tolerancing, but it was a great exercise in thinking about what kinds of designs could be possible. During the ideation stage, the bulk of my time was spent surveying people both online and in person to figure out if others also saw a need for such products. After doing over 200 surveys, I noticed that most people’s interest in customized structures revolved around furniture, and many people did indeed share my frustration with the dichotomy of “fast” versus luxury options.

    Fast iteration through 3D printing

    Top left and right: Locking pin connector design. Bottom left and right: Spring locking clip connector design.
    Top left and right: Locking pin connector design. Bottom left and right: Spring locking clip connector design.
    Thanks to the increased accessibility of 3D printing, going through the first handful of prototype concepts was a breeze. At this stage I explored a variety of ideas, from self-clipping connectors that required more than 200 pounds of push force to engage (impossible!) to more refined connectors that utilized a plastic locking insert or spring lock. Through this process, my knowledge in 3D printing and rapid prototyping grew exponentially, and I began thinking about ways to cut prototyping costs and increase efficiency even further.

    Finding the limits of 3D tests

    Left: Using epoxy resin to duplicate 3D-printed parts. Right: A simple plywood stool using our connectors to form the legs. It couldn’t carry significant weight, but it worked as a proof of concept.
    Left: Using epoxy resin to duplicate 3D-printed parts. Right: A simple plywood stool using our connectors to form the legs. It couldn’t carry significant weight, but it worked as a proof of concept.
    After more than 20 different concepts, the first item tested on a fully assembled design was the connector with locking spring clips. One challenge I encountered at this point was that I needed more than 10 sets of connectors to do any meaningful assembly tests. High quality (SLS) 3D printing had long lead times and was quite expensive, so I got creative with DIY molding and hand forming methods to cut time and cost. Plastic concepts worked well for visualizing the idea, and I was getting more confident that the interchangeable connector system could actually work, but I still wondered how I would ever be able to accurately test the manufacturability and strength of the furniture with just 3D-printed plastic parts.

    Turning to suppliers reveals new setbacks

    Top left: First sample produced with die casting methods. Top right: Hardened spring clip (before and after). Bottom left and right: Sample after powder coating finish.
    Top left: First sample produced with die casting methods. Top right: Hardened spring clip (before and after). Bottom left and right: Sample after powder coating finish.
    I started a month-long search for die casting, continuous forming, and extrusion suppliers (for the connectors, spring clips, and beams, respectively). Die casting and extrusion methods are some of the most economically viable aluminum manufacturing processes, so my design for manufacturing (DFM) focused on these methods. I sought out suppliers who would agree to make small sample runs, and after hours of meetings and design reviews, I finally had my first production samples in hand.
    These samples helped shine a light on many problems that I hadn’t encountered before. First of all, the connectors were way too heavy, due to their unnecessarily thick cross section, and the spring clips were almost impossible to remove once attached to the beams. The difference in flexibility between plastic and aluminum parts made the spring clip design difficult to assemble—and not reusable. I felt defeated, but I learned exactly what to expect from manufacturing. To keep the principles of “eliminating muda” and “kaizen” in check, it was time to go back to the drawing board.

    Back to the drawing board for a more lightweight concept

    Left: Ideation of product possibilities with the new connector design. Top right: CNC machined sample of new connector concept—notice the mirrored design and hollow cavities. Bottom right: One of our earliest marketing shots, taken to push sales of preorders.
    Left: Ideation of product possibilities with the new connector design. Top right: CNC machined sample of new connector concept—notice the mirrored design and hollow cavities. Bottom right: One of our earliest marketing shots, taken to push sales of preorders.
    After many more iterations, I finally settled on a concept that would become the first version of Aalo’s commercial product. The new connector design had mirrored top and bottom components with thin walls, which weighed 70 percent less than the previous concept and eliminated the need for spring clips. Finally, a functional minimum viable product (MVP) was born. I had been developing this for eight months, and I couldn’t wait to see what consumers would think of Aalo. Even before figuring out manufacturing, I put together a landing page and started spreading the word through online communities such as Product Hunt and Reddit.

    I learned—the hard way—that I really should have checked my factory’s work

    Details of missing geometry from our first production parts. Failure to handle quality check in a more direct manner resulted in more time and money wasted.
    Details of missing geometry from our first production parts. Failure to handle quality check in a more direct manner resulted in more time and money wasted.
    The hard work seemed to have paid off, and I felt ecstatic to have my first paying customers. However, what followed is a tale that most hardware founders know all too well.
    In order to get a small batch of the parts manufactured as soon as possible, I rushed back to the manufacturers to put in a new order. A local supplier made the extrusions, so I was able to keep a close eye on the process, but the communication with overseas suppliers was difficult to manage. Despite many warnings, I made the mistake of not flying over to physically check the quality of the parts while I had the chance. When the initial batch came in, every single connector had a defect where a critical piece of end bit was missing from the design, even though the quality inspection report had all the right numbers. Panic and anxiety kicked in. I knew this meant significant delays fulfilling orders for the customers who were so excited to support Aalo.

    Processing orders with friends and family was fun, but not scalable

    Top left: Visiting die casting vendor in Shenzhen, China, and doing hands-on quality check. Top right: Visiting extrusion vendor in Toronto, Canada, for quality inspection. Bottom left: Packing and sorting parts for shipment. Bottom right: Products finally began to ship!
    Top left: Visiting die casting vendor in Shenzhen, China, and doing hands-on quality check. Top right: Visiting extrusion vendor in Toronto, Canada, for quality inspection. Bottom left: Packing and sorting parts for shipment. Bottom right: Products finally began to ship!
    The whole ordeal taught me to never cut corners on quality assurance, no matter the cost. Thinking that it’s better late than never, I flew over to China to kick off production with a more qualified vendor we met through a fellow entrepreneur. I spent over a month there to make sure the parts were up to spec. By this time, we had 60 preorders waiting to be sent out. I went back to Canada and began cutting, packaging, and shipping all of the orders day and night with the help of my close friends in a small warehouse I rented.
    Another lesson learned? Help from friends and family is definitely not scalable, and your time is valuable. Factor the labor, post-production, and packaging into your cost of goods from the beginning, as it can make or break your business model later on.

    Continuous improvement through customer contact

    Watching and helping customers as they put together Aalo for the first time.
    Watching and helping customers as they put together Aalo for the first time.
    Now that orders were being shipped out, it was time to collect feedback from customers and hear what they had to say. The best way to do that? Watch them assemble your product! I made a total of 12 visits to different customers’ homes in California and Canada to interact with them and get their thoughts. Everything from first impressions to opinions on the assembly process was crucial to the Toyota continuous improvement (kaizen) philosophy I wanted to bring into my work.
    Setting up logistics was challenging, but I was able to do it because my gracious customers didn’t hesitate to let a stranger (me) walk into their homes to watch them assemble Aalo. Feedback gathered from this experience became the foundation of Aalo version 2.0.
    Introducing Aalo 2.0
    Aalo 2.0: Adaptable, durable & sustainable furniture designed for city living.
    Aalo 2.0: Adaptable, durable & sustainable furniture designed for city living.
    Aalo 2.0 is a culmination of a year and a half of development and customer feedback, and it’s an improved model in multiple aspects. The connector material was changed to zinc to give it 40 percent more load-bearing strength and six times better impact strength, and the tips now have a grooved profile to provide better grip during assembly. As for the beams and panels, the slotted portions are designed to be snap-fit, so that assembly is now much easier even for bulky items.
    Evolution of connector designs, from left to right. We will continue to improve on these designs to make Aalo better.
    Evolution of connector designs, from left to right. We will continue to improve on these designs to make Aalo better.
    With the launch of Aalo 2.0 on Kickstarter, we want to introduce our new product to this forward-thinking audience and build an even stronger community to fuel our future growth. We’ll continue to stay true to our philosophy of continuously improving our products to be better in every aspect, and to build the world’s most flexible furniture system.
    Aalo is live on Kickstarter through June 8, 2019.
    Kickstarter just turned 10. This photo essay by Sejun Park is part of a series that celebrates past projects and introduces a few new ones. Read more here.
    Comments (6)
    Nutri Plan
    We should always choose high quality furniture for our home and offices. Furniture is most important equipment inside a building so we should feel hesitation while buying good stuff as you have mentioned in this article. Well, now I would like to visit https://studyclerk.com/write-research-paper-for-me website to hire an expert writer who will write my research paper for me at cheap rates.
    Jennifer lopez
    Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us. https://sites.google.com/site/be...
    Lowry Lowry
    You can check https://broadapk.com/blog/best-s... and get to manage your android apps.
    JaniceB JaniceB
    While the idea of designing a website might seem like a fun and easy project, it is actually a very complicated one. If you’re going to design a website, you need to be very well-versed in the basics of web design and internet marketing. The best way to learn is to master the basics and master them in an intensive practical way. Lets check https://masterbundles.com/fresh-design-trends/ and get information about the fresh designs and fonts. Exactly how you learn this will depend on what kind of business you have, but even if it’s just for fun, you should're ready to make some improvements as soon as possible.
    James Horst
    As an engineer at https://coolair247.co.uk/ working everyday with small parts (ventilation systems, air conditioning and so on) I appreciate that kind of usage for 3D printing. It has been a blessing. So keep doing you!