As an algorithmic trading firm, this will be a GODSEND for us when all our algos are implemented. I haven't been this excited about a platform launch in a long long time.
Pros:
- Super easy to use, very responsive and helpful team.
- TradingView support coming soon (this is huge)
Cons:
- Still a bit early in the stage, but from the looks of it the team is motivated to make lots new features quickly.
Really nice platform that allows me to deliver quality strategies to retail clients. Big jump in democratising crypto bot trading with real backtests, finally a platform where people can see how a strategy really performed before throwing their money into a black hole.
@caid@imrgoyal But this platform is for US users only right? It says so in your own Terms and Conditions! Shouldnt you let your 70%+ users who are not US based know this?
Mudrex is an amazing trading platform combining the simplisity of programming using blocks with trading algorithms, there is an amazing discord group where you can ask questions, ranging from getting-started to serious discussions about the latest strategy developments.
The support of the community and especially of the dev-team is amazing, I for one asked for a certain indicator to be added and the next update it was added!
I'm surprised that Mudrex isn't already at the top of algorithm-trading platforms, because simply put, the capabilities and potential for it to be number one is already there! 10/10
@tijn_van_de_heuvel@imrgoyal But this is not GDPR compliant and Mudrex employees have access to your private trading strategies. 30% commissions? A bit far I think @shaggy_ks
@imrgoyal
1. "We shall retain 30% of the Marketplace Payments and transfer 70% "
2. "We make no claims concerning whether the Content may be downloaded, viewed, or be appropriate for use outside of the United States. If you access the Site, or the Content from outside of the United States, you do so at your own risk. "
When Mudrex launched today and within the first 2 hours got over 100 likes and 6 reviews, all positive, I was intrigued, especially since only yesterday, the much awaited and publicized Facebook Libra launch got only HALF those numbers in the same time span. My statistical brain was intrigued so I decided to dig, sensing potential foul play. When I then noticed that a lot of the upvotes were from new users and half of the positive reviews were from users who had never upvoted or had any prior activity on PH, things got interesting. The Mudrex launch was not a casual affair: it was carefully timed to coincide with Facebook’s Libra and ride that wave. To wit, the HUNTER of Libra yesterday is one of the MAKERS of Mudrex today. For those who know, I do in depth reviews so “here we go again”. In the comments below, I show how Mudrex although explicitly soliciting users from across the globe, is legal and made for US users ONLY, which right now form less than 30% of their overall user base. Then there is the issue of jeopardy to users who are using a product that may lead to criminal liabilities. Then I dissect the questionable business practices of charging 30% commissions AND piggybacking off users’ trading strategies. Finally, I show some of the numerous security flaws in the product itself. For the Mudrex guys(since I didn't see any female employees listed): please take these as learning points and constructive criticism. Yes I am somewhat direct but this is free feedback. I hope you can use these to make changes and better the product as it IS an interesting idea.
Pros:
Good idea but terrible and questionably unethical execution.
Cons:
1. 30% commissions: ridiculous.
2. For US users ONLY.
3. Mt Gox like security issues.
4. Unethical vote stacking and fake reviews.
Hi John,
To clarify, all of your points you shared in the cons are factually incorrect.
1) There is no charge from marketplace investors except the subscription charges.
2) More than 50% of our users are outside of US.
3) Mt. Gox doesn't apply. We don't hold custody.
4) You can join our discord group and can find almost each single reviewer there.
@imrgoyal
1. From your TOS: "We shall retain 30% of the Marketplace Payments and transfer 70% "
2. Yes but your TOS makes clear this site is for US users only: "We make no claims concerning whether the Content may be downloaded, viewed, or be appropriate for use outside of the United States. If you access the Site, or the Content from outside of the United States, you do so at your own risk. "
3. Yes but there are security issues that arise from API access. Custody I already talked about.
4. Yes but funny how they are all NEW to PH. I didnt say there is foul play just very interesting compared to "regular" PH launches.
@imrgoyal@john_vonroth As a casual observer and user of Mudrex (otherwise no affiliation), this seems kind of sloppy and irresponsible criticism.
1. This applies to entities selling subscriptions to their strategies. I subscribe to a strategy and do not pay 30% of anything.
2. What's wrong with a disclaimer? Essentially they are saying that they think it's kosher in the US but can't be sure about the other 194 countries. DYOR.
3. Access to exchange API is a universal practice when trading on centralized exchanges and is employed by dozens of companies. It's not Mt. Gox and you know that. Why exaggerate?
4. This is my first PH review and I'm a real person.
wrt the rest of your comments... maybe spend an hour on the site to understand a bit more and check out the enthusiasm of users in their Discord. Hopefully you'll be a bit more charitable.
Mudrex is phenomenal. I understood how code and logic worked, but the plug and play ability to put those concepts into practice using drag and drop coding blocks was game changing for me as a Cryptocurrency daytrader. Their discord has a great community!
I can see you are supporting long short and many other functionalities in trading which generally people don't find on exchanges. any future integration plans ?
@viraj_shah2 Thanks for asking this. We support shorts for exchanges which themselves support shorting, currently only on Bitmex. Coinbase Pro is going live within 2 weeks and couple of other exchanges are on the pipeline.
Other than that some other advanced features are coming to help traders build even better trading strategies like
- Custom indicators: which would let traders use their pine script based custom indicators
- limit ordering capabilities to help traders reduce slippage
- Pyramid ordering to average out buy and sell price and increase profits
- Better risk management capabilities
Ultimately all of these will lead to better strategies on marketplace.
@ruchi_sharma We only list high liquidity coins to minimise market manipulations. You would be able to check that only 25% of all the Binance assets pairs are available on Mudrex.
This is looking good people.
I just love the user interface which allows you to create cryptocurrency trading strategies without coding. Mudrex also allows you to backtest any strategy with the settings you choose. Besides backtesting there's also paper trading and for anyone who doesnt wan't to create his/her own strategy there's the marketplace where you can subscribe to existing strategies made by the pro's!
I'm excited! And this seems to be only the beginning.
Pros:
- Superb user interface
- Backtesting and Papertrading integrated
- The Marketplace!
@lucas_p Aaron and Brownie both have been using the product since quite a while and both have been making money. Looking forward to have you try out the product and share your feedback. :)
Love it. Have been using it for a while and didn't marketplace was on the roadmap. This is perfect for non traders like me. Can you clarify your business model? How much can I trade on a single strategy? Is there any minimum or maximum amount I can invest on a strategy
@kar2905 Thanks for asking these questions. All the strategies on the marketplace are published by pro traders only and have gone through rigorous review process to maintain quality.
Business Model:
Trader publishes a strategy on the marketplace and define a monthly fee she wants to charge. Investors can subscribe to a strategy by paying monthly subscription fee. We take 30% of that subscription fee and 70% is passed on to the strategy creator.
Retail investor can invest any amount they want to invest on a strategy. So though we haven't defined any minimum and maximum amount as of now we usually reach out to people wanting to invest more than $20k to bring fair terms for traders and investors.
@shrutweets_ Thanks for the wishes. We are working on making it even simpler from the existing interface for people who just want to invest. For the time being you can see past performance of the strategies and choose considering your risk appetite. Our community is the best place to jump in for recommendations.
Been using Mudrex for about 3 months, and I can say that I learned more about the market than any course I took in youtube! Their discord group is super helpful and friendly, the team in mudrex are very intuitive , and The User interface is simple. All in all I would give this fantastic website a 10/10
Pros:
- Clean UI
- Amazing team
- Fast backtest
- Feature request are always added
-Amazing discord group
Really love the product design here. Mudrex entry into the crypto market is perfectly timed too. Was just looking for an easy way to get into algorithmic trading.
This is an absolute charm for the algorithmic trading world. Literally slashes away huge time investments through their intuitive drag drop features.almost gives a creative edge to visualise your strategies. This is a phenomenal use case and I would wish the mudrex team to improve upon all the feedback because this is truly a potential LAMBO product. Absolutely remarkable.
Mudrex Marketplace
@minimalnotpoor Thanks for your kind words. The whole team is working hard day and night to improve existing product and build new features which helps traders create better algorithms.
One of the early users of the platform, sincerely believe there is a market big enough for good automated trading strategies, which people can subscribe to... win win for both the traders and the users who will use their strategies.. Keep up the good work guys @edul_patel1
@edul_patel1@aditya_ahluwalia Thanks for your continuous support and helping us shape the product in the right direction. It is been a pleasure having you on board since early days and having you publish your strategy on the marketplace. :)
@sumukh_shetty Thanks for your positive feedback Sumukh. Having you as one of the first investor on Mudrex marketplace has helped us shaping the product in the right direction.
Replies
As an algorithmic trading firm, this will be a GODSEND for us when all our algos are implemented. I haven't been this excited about a platform launch in a long long time.
Pros:- Super easy to use, very responsive and helpful team. - TradingView support coming soon (this is huge)
Cons:- Still a bit early in the stage, but from the looks of it the team is motivated to make lots new features quickly.
SatoshiGPT
Tuned
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
@imrgoyal 1. "We shall retain 30% of the Marketplace Payments and transfer 70% " 2. "We make no claims concerning whether the Content may be downloaded, viewed, or be appropriate for use outside of the United States. If you access the Site, or the Content from outside of the United States, you do so at your own risk. " When Mudrex launched today and within the first 2 hours got over 100 likes and 6 reviews, all positive, I was intrigued, especially since only yesterday, the much awaited and publicized Facebook Libra launch got only HALF those numbers in the same time span. My statistical brain was intrigued so I decided to dig, sensing potential foul play. When I then noticed that a lot of the upvotes were from new users and half of the positive reviews were from users who had never upvoted or had any prior activity on PH, things got interesting. The Mudrex launch was not a casual affair: it was carefully timed to coincide with Facebook’s Libra and ride that wave. To wit, the HUNTER of Libra yesterday is one of the MAKERS of Mudrex today. For those who know, I do in depth reviews so “here we go again”. In the comments below, I show how Mudrex although explicitly soliciting users from across the globe, is legal and made for US users ONLY, which right now form less than 30% of their overall user base. Then there is the issue of jeopardy to users who are using a product that may lead to criminal liabilities. Then I dissect the questionable business practices of charging 30% commissions AND piggybacking off users’ trading strategies. Finally, I show some of the numerous security flaws in the product itself. For the Mudrex guys(since I didn't see any female employees listed): please take these as learning points and constructive criticism. Yes I am somewhat direct but this is free feedback. I hope you can use these to make changes and better the product as it IS an interesting idea.
Pros:Good idea but terrible and questionably unethical execution.
Cons:1. 30% commissions: ridiculous. 2. For US users ONLY. 3. Mt Gox like security issues. 4. Unethical vote stacking and fake reviews.
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
This is looking good people. I just love the user interface which allows you to create cryptocurrency trading strategies without coding. Mudrex also allows you to backtest any strategy with the settings you choose. Besides backtesting there's also paper trading and for anyone who doesnt wan't to create his/her own strategy there's the marketplace where you can subscribe to existing strategies made by the pro's! I'm excited! And this seems to be only the beginning.
Pros:- Superb user interface - Backtesting and Papertrading integrated - The Marketplace!
Cons:No Cons i know of
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
EngageWith Suggestion Box
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
If you haven’t been to Mudrex you really should come and Make your own decision. It is amazinf
Pros:bridges gap between coding and algo trading. You can make very profitable algo trading strategies with NO code. Simple, great team, evolving
Cons:Wish it was there 3 years ago
SatoshiGPT
Been using Mudrex for about 3 months, and I can say that I learned more about the market than any course I took in youtube! Their discord group is super helpful and friendly, the team in mudrex are very intuitive , and The User interface is simple. All in all I would give this fantastic website a 10/10
Pros:- Clean UI - Amazing team - Fast backtest - Feature request are always added -Amazing discord group
Cons:- None so far
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT
SatoshiGPT