Choosy Chat
p/choosy-chat
Chooses the best answer from the top 3 AIs.
Gabor Cselle
Choosy Chat — Chooses the best answer between GPT, Gemini, and Claude
Featured
59
Choosy will choose the best answer between ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude.
Replies
Gabor Cselle
One thing I do a lot is: 1. I go to ChatGPT and type in a difficult question … and them I’m not satisfied with the answer … 2. .. then I go to Gemini and copy-paste the question from ChatGPT … 3. .. and finally I paste the question into Claude as well. If you've ever done the same, Choosy Chat is for you: You’ll see results streaming in from the models. Once they’re complete, Choosy Cat will choose the best answer. You can continue the conversation based on any one of the 3 answers. You can share the convo with a coworker, and much more. And don't panic, yes, there is Dark Mode. I wouldn't dare to launch on Product Hunt without it.
Michiel Rauws
@gabor yep happens to me all the time! which model often turns out to be your favorite?
Gabor Cselle
@michiel_rauws Currently GPT-4o, but waiting for access to the new Gemini model that just came out which has better ELO ratings.
Rajiv Ayyangar
@gabor thanks for dark mode! What’s the delay vs picking a single chat?
Gabor Cselle
@rajiv_ayyangar Thanks Rajiv! All answers stream in in real-time, so there's no delay. The best answer is picked only once all the answers are received, so that does take time.
Abhishek
@gabor What is the average response time versus chatting with a single model? Also, how does CC choose the best answer? (or, which AI model is choosing that for us?)
Bikram Agarwal
Should've mentioned the "3 questions / month" limit before I signed-up! 😒
Alan Yang
@vicky_buddie if you like it! You can sign up for a plan for $5, even cheaper if you use our code!
Michiel Rauws
When I'm working on looking data for a specific project I usually find that one of the models more often than not performs better. I love this tool as it's much less copy pasting to compare answers. What projects have you found it most useful for?
Gabor Cselle
@michiel_rauws Yeah I find the same. I find it best for coding questions, and also for parsing really dense academic papers (via the attachment feature).
Pere
This sounds like a really smart solution! I've totally been there, bouncing between different AI chatbots trying to find the perfect answer. I'm curious how you decide which answer is "best" – is it based on facts, how it sounds, or something else? And what happens when none of the answers are great?
Alan Yang
@perewari Thanks Pere - It's an LLM-based critic model - that's kind of the secret sauce. Follow-up questions and context are carried through multiple turns of the conversation, you can pick the best response at each turn of the conversation, and all the LLMs will be given that context.
blank
Loving the concept of Choosy, @gabor! The ability to compare answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude streamlines the decision-making process. It's like having a personal assistant to sort through the noise and help find that perfect answer. Plus, the capability to continue conversations based on any of the responses is a huge win for collaboration! 🏆 Dark Mode is definitely a must-have. It feels great to see that you're keeping user experience in mind. I'm excited to see how this helps with productivity and efficiency! Have you considered any integration features for team platforms? That might enhance the functionality even further. Can’t wait to watch this launch and see the traction it gains!
Gabor Cselle
@blankwebdev Thank you, glad you like it. I've once faced a user revolt for removing dark mode on a previous project, so I know of its importance.
Jason Levin
omg u can now choose ur chatbot in 1 place, love it.
Alan Yang
@iamjasonlevin Thanks Jason!
Giuseppe Della Corte
I love the concept and the UI @gabor! Simple, easy, effective, useful :)
Gabor Cselle
@gdc Thank you!
Glen Dsouza
Congrats on the launch! How does Choosy Cat give you the best answer? what does it take into consideration? If I have a scenario question and use gemini as well as GPT and both give me different but correct answers, how will Choosy Cat help me with the best? I'd also suggest having both gemini and GPT answers show up along with a reasoning on why that particular answer would be the best. Just my thoughts 😅
Alan Yang
@glen_dsouza_1 Hi Glen, It's an LLM-based critic model - that's kind of the secret sauce. Follow-up questions and context are carried through multiple turns of the conversation, you can pick the best response at each turn of the conversation, and all the LLMs will be given that context.
Ghost Kitty
Comment Deleted
Alan Yang
@gabor @zulkarnaim Thanks Zulkar - hope you enjoy it!
Kyrylo Silin
Hey Gabor, Choosy Chat sounds like a useful tool for comparing AI responses. I'm curious how it determines which answer is "best" - what criteria does it use? How does it handle follow-up questions or maintaining context across multiple turns of conversation? Congrats on the launch!
Gabor Cselle
@kyrylosilin It's an LLM-based critic model - that's kind of the secret sauce. Follow-up questions and context are carried through multiple turns of the conversation, you can pick the best response at each turn of the conversation, and all the LLMs will be given that context.
Tariq Waseem
Interesting idea! I have not seen an app like it, appreciate your project!
Toshit Garg
Congrats on launch of Choosy Cat....
Gabor Cselle
@toshit_garg Thank you, Choosy is a happy cat today.
Yahya Aghattass
Lol. I just thought about something similar this morning. It's super helpful for me. Good luck, Gabor
Alan Yang
@yahya_aghattass Thanks Yahya - hope you enjoy using it!
Finlay O'Neill
Really like the simplicity alongside the familiar design that users of these tools will be used to. Good luck
Gabor Cselle
@finlay_oneill Thank you!
Barsha Ghosh
Very innovative i like the simplicity..
Alan Yang
@barsha_ghosh3 Thanks Barsha!
Sahir Maharaj
Congrats on your new app, @gabor! The interface is super user-friendly and the color palette is gorgeous. Navigation is a breeze, making it really easy to use. Can’t wait to incorporate this into my daily routine!
Gabor Cselle
@sahirmaharaj Thank you Sahir!
Maka
Congratulations on the launch! The ability to view results streaming from different models and select the best answer in one place is such a game-changer.How did you determine the criteria for Choosy Cat to select the "best" answer?
Alan Yang
@maka_4 Thanks Maka - It's an LLM-based critic model - that's kind of the secret sauce. Follow-up questions and context are carried through multiple turns of the conversation, you can pick the best response at each turn of the conversation, and all the LLMs will be given that context.
Henry
It's always great to have a Dark Mode option. Thank you for considering this; it makes working at night much easier!
Alan Yang
@h_henry Thanks Henry, thats always been a request from users!
Jane
The feature that allows sharing conversations with a coworker could vastly improve collaborative efforts in a team setting. Are there any limitations on the number of coworkers that can access a shared conversation?
Alan Yang
@jane0621 Thanks Jane, ideally if we each person has their own account, sharing conversations is a feature we will take note of!
Moumita Bandyopadhyay
Really like the simplicity alongside the familiar design that users of these tools will be used to. Good luckCongrats on the launch! 🌟 Your hard work and dedication have paid off. I'm excited to see the impact it will have. I'll definitely use it and spread the word!
Gabor Cselle
@bubun_ganguly Thank you Moumita!